This is the twentieth time or so I’ve tried to write here in the last month and a half. I’m determined to succeed this time, despite my fear of doing so. I got a few notes from people starting to earnestly worry about me: I certainly didn’t need to make anyone worry, but do appreciate the concern. Given my time lapse, and how complex everything is, there’s going to be a lot to read here today, and it’s going to read a whole lot like a confession, even though I’d prefer it didn’t. I don’t really know how to do this: I expect to be clumsy, which feels like my default these days.
A lot of my silence has had to do with waiting for a very, very big shoe to drop. The long and the short of it is that the once-primary relationship — a marriage — Blue has been in for over a decade has been troubled and deteriorating for quite some time: years before we even started talking again, let alone renewed our romantic and sexual relationship last winter. And it has now led to his taking the first steps of a divorce. I haven’t felt comfortable sharing that aspect of all of this until now because…well, wait.
I still don’t feel comfortable sharing, but I feel even more uncomfortable not doing so. I don’t like keeping secrets, especially big, nasty ones. I don’t like being secrets, either. All the same, I haven’t felt okay about even thinking about disclosing that until this point. Both knowing (which I have for some months) what choices Blue wanted to make, and having those choices begin to be enacted was something I needed before I talked about it publicly, for everyone’s sake.
Let me get this out of the way: in general, I don’t care if someone is married, so long as it isn’t me. However, I have always had a hard and fast rule about dating or sleeping with anyone who is married, even if it’s an open marriage by full and glad agreement: I don’t do it. The one time I was with someone who I found out wasn’t truthful with me about the status of a marriage, I put an immediate end to the relationship, even though it was an important one I didn’t want to sever. If I went into all my reasoning around why that’s been my rule, I’d have too easy a distraction, but the crux of it is my feelings about marriage, honesty, honoring people’s existing agreements (and dating people who honor their relationship agreements), emotional availability, how much drama I’m up for and what I want and need in my life. I also have been close to too many messy, ugly divorces in my life, with family, with friends, and I want to be as far from divorce — always a possibility with any marriage — as humanly possible.
I made an exception this time, which I’ve had mixed feelings about. Because I did go outside my own ethics, ethics I tend to broadcast, I feel a need to explain why. I made that exception because of the nature of both my and Blue’s relationship, now and in the past, because of my understanding of Blue’s relationship with his wife, because of existing nonmonogamy over there for years before I was back on the scene, and because my feelings for Blue and vice-versa are very strong and enduring. I’ll also be honest: given our long and complex history and how we have always been when together, beyond my usual bristling at the idea of anyone having ownership of someone else, the idea that Blue is “someone else’s” just isn’t how this feels or has felt. Not to me, not to him. I made an exception because we both felt gypped at not having another chance to be together at a time in our lives when we could finally handle it. I made an exception because a lot of this — most of this — just felt right, and because in weighing my options, not pursuing this as we have felt like a choice I’d regret more than I would in pursuing it. I don’t intend to absolve myself of any responsibility for my choices, but in terms of how it has felt and it feels, this hasn’t been one of those things where I’ve been all, “I’m not proud of what I’ve done, but….” I’m neither proud nor not proud. In making my choices, I consulted at great length with my heart and head, and with people close to me who I know care about me a lot, understand me, and hold me to the same kinds of standards I hold myself to. I also made an exception because we both intended the way things have been to be temporary.
The end of this marriage isn’t about me: it’s been creeping towards this for some years now after efforts to repair problems for a very long time, and also has not been a sexually active relationship for a long time. Both for longer than I’ve ever even been in a romantic relationship, which is an odd perspective to have. As far as nonomonogamy over there has gone, they have had is what I describe as a passive agreement to active ignorance (and not the pejorative meaning). There’s essentially an agreement to denial, rather than to an open relationship, and some interpersonal structures built to provide certain freedoms for nonmonogamy while keeping a strongly padlocked silence about it.
It has not been something workable for me in anything but the short-term, if that. Even in that limited way, I don’t see my ever agreeing to this with anyone but Blue. I’m not down with multiple partnership like that where everyone isn’t talking and negotiating as a collective, especially with relationships as serious and loaded as these. I also feel conflicted with anything — even when it’s a choice one woman has made — that keeps women from connecting with one another.
However, it’s not my relationship, so I’ve tried to be a grownup and not project what I think is kosher for me or in general unto them. Suffice it to say, I can have a certain arrogance about things like this as an occupational hazard, especially if I’m not mindful about it. I’ve tried to deal only with my and Blue’s relationship and how their stuff involves me. What I could address, obviously, is our relationship, and both what I can live with and want to live with. I had my ducks in a row over here on my end, and my agreements with Mark sorted already; I had from the get-go.
So, back in March, Blue and I made an agreement that by fall, he would either a) create an open and fully honest agreement per he and I within his marriage — which included the honesty that he wasn’t with some random person, but with me, as well as that he wanted me to become a primary partner — b) for that relationship to switch to a fully acknowledged platonic relationship and/or for the legal marriage to be dissolved, or c) for the model of our relationship to change so that it became a platonic friendship, either permanently or until one of the other options was wanted and chosen.
It wasn’t an ultimatum. In fact, if his marriage wasn’t in disrepair already, and it was meeting Blue’s needs, in many ways I’d have preferred the first of the three options.
The why of that is complex, but I know part of it is that I just hate any a situation where one person is chosen “over” another or perceives things that way no matter who it is getting chosen, even when it’s me. (Maybe in some ways especially when it’s me.) My internal sense of fairness revolts at it, as does my core feeling that we all have room for infinite love in our hearts; room for far more than one person we love in life, and I don’t understand why we accept that as a culture with friends and family, but not with sexual or romantic relationships. This “pick one” thing just doesn’t sit well with me when it’s about people. I also know that Blue has a lot of love for the person he’s married to, and has valued many aspects of their relationship. I hate to see love lost. However, this is another area in which I’ve needed to work on being an adult when it comes to what other people choose and what they want. I didn’t have a say in their relationship, to how they structured and lived it: that was all about their choices, choices made a long time before Blue and I reconnected and renewed our relationship.
In any event, Blue wound up choosing door #2. At this point, discussion of he and I has not yet happened between he and his wife. I sit on that precipice very, very nervously, the same way I’d sit in the open maw of a lion. I don’t know what’s going to happen when they get to that point, especially since it’ll mean his breaking an enforced silence on a bunch of things she/they clearly just has/have not wanted to face or address. His disclosures around nonmonogamy are going to be one thing when talking about other partners, but most likely something else when it comes to me.
I’m not entirely sure if it’s okay for me to talk about this here, but it’s really heavy for me and no small part of all this, so I’m going to say it for now and hope I don’t trespass. I’m a very loaded person in that relationship, and that’s age-old: in many ways I’ve been the most loaded person in that relationship since it began. I started out the bad guy (or rather, girl) for them both: I was the terrible person who broke Blue’s heart, who in some ways he was treated as needing nursing from. In some ways I’m sure that he did, of course, but there was a lot of demonization there, some of which I understand now, but still don’t like. I, or the history of myself and Blue, seems to have been a foil for some of their problematic dynamics. Mind, I don’t think that was fair. I was 22 years old when I left Blue and in the middle of very terrifying, overwhelming and unanticipated PTSD that took some things away from me (or seemed like it did) that I deeply cherished and felt utterly lost without. As well, Blue and I had some shared issues, and he had his own missteps. I had a fight-or-flight impulse, and I flew. I handled it all badly, without question, and only after finally really working through all of it together last year did I stop feeling horrible about some of what I did which I know was awful. However, I didn’t mean to hurt him: I was trying to protect and guard myself with limited skills and a mind that was in total disarray. So, not fair, but that’s not all that relevant: a lot isn’t fair in life and love, and it’s very clear at this point that they were probably more hurt, and will be more hurt, in creating that dynamic around me than I was or will be.
It’s a bit tough not to feel like something of a homewrecker, though, even though I know that’s not what went on, nor what is going on, and not at all what anyone intended or wanted. But I anticipate it may be perceived or presented that way, especially since it’ll probably be more comfortable in some ways to point at me rather than acknowledging tougher or more painful truths. If it is, if I am, presented that way, I don’t know how I’ll deal with it. If I’m honest, I have to acknowledge that I have equal parts sympathy and a total lack of sympathy in that department. I feel some guilt around this, particularly because I know that there has always been a good deal of jealousy in terms of the strong feelings he has had for me, as well as a (obviously valid) fear he’d choose to be with me instead of her. I would never want anyone to feel like they were in or lost some kind of competition to me for someone else’s heart: that just sounds abhorrent to me. I don’t even want to be even a tangential cause of someone’s pain. Suffice it to say, I have a lot of sympathy for anyone losing Blue in any way: I know too well how painful that can be. On the other hand, I have to be kind to myself and cut myself a break knowing that this is not a dynamic I set up: that was someone else’s choice, not mine. I made clear what I felt and wanted a long time ago, and that last time around, in Act II of all of this, I stepped aside without argument to allow Blue to choose to go to her when a “choose one” was their deal, even though it was the last thing I wanted to do, it hurt like hell and I was the walking wounded for a couple years afterward.
It still sucks that this dynamic exists, regardless, and I still don’t look forward to facing it, but expect I will have to. That everyone will have to. But maybe we’ve all needed to, perhaps for longer than any of us have realized.
Okay, taking a breath. Now another one. One more.
I realize there’s another reason why this has been so tough for me to voice here, even once I had the criteria I thought I needed, we all needed, for me to do so.
It makes me feel small to admit it, but one benefit of having and living very stringent ethics is that it allows you a certain lack of vulnerability. In some ways, a perception of you being superhuman and perhaps not as flawed and fallible as everyone else. Even if it’s not why you choose your ethics, certain standards of living and thinking do put you on a pedestal to some degree. They can protect you from some measure of judgment. Of course, if that is the case, however rough some of this is, that’s very important for me to ditch, especially since it may well be part of some treatment or perception of me in life I don’t actually like and which can feel very isolating.
Let’s also face it, I’m hardly anonymous, and putting this out there does make me nervous in terms of my job and position in the world. I know all too well that there are some individuals and groups who will relish evidence that I am the immoral, skanky harlot who is out to wreck families and traditional relationships it’s been sometimes suggested I am. I’ve joked about it among friends sometimes, that that’s my easy out, my being everything some have said or implied I was in the first place. But my jesting there comes out of guarding how vulnerable it makes me feel and my desire not to be that person.
I’d be remiss to leave out that disclosing all of this means that if I wind up with egg on my face I can’t hide it. (I was so close to typing “…then the yolk’s on me” instead. I’m very sorry that I still did it.)
And that’d all be some of why I was so quiet. Believe it or not, that is only some.
It’s been rough to figure out how to talk about Mark and I, too. Some of what came out in all the communication around the poly agreement last winter was a level of honesty Mark had withheld from me – and himself, really — that was so rough for me. It wasn’t anything malicious, cruel or purposefully deceptive. At worst, I’d say it was careless, but at the same time Mark and I have had very different lives, very different levels of experience with relationships and very different personal growth experiences. All the same, what came out hurt me deeply in some ways, and was a dealbreaker for me when it came to us having the kind of relationship we had been building, or that I thought we had. I don’t mean to be obtuse, but it’s not my right to spill Mark’s guts for him on the Internet, so what I’ll just say is that I want and need certain things in a relationship of this depth and level of commitment that just didn’t mesh with how Mark was feeling, thinking and constructing his own frameworks.
It’s not an honesty I regret, and it was a brave one on Mark’s part that I’m exceptionally grateful for. I think when this kind of stuff comes out of poly — as it tends to since you’re usually deepening communication a lot — it’s so convenient for people to blame the poly, and this just isn’t poly’s fault. A lot of good things have come out of us opening the relationship up at the end of last year: I’d number those tough truths among them, even though the outcome of that truth led to a split. I think, though, it’s probably also going to lead us both in directions that will result in both of us getting what we really want and also coming to whatever our best relationship is. Mark still feels like my family: I have a hard time imagining Mark will ever feel like, or be, anything but. Mark’s family feels like my family, and they’ve made that clear on their end, too. Mark also remains, however sticky some things are right this second, one of my very best friends in the world. Visualizing a life without him in it makes no sense to me. And some of all that is why it’s been tricky to talk about what went down with us: I’m a ferociously loyal person with those near and dear to me, and can be very protective.
Over the years, I have kept finding that one area where it gets tough to write here about my personal life is all about loyalty. Sometimes, it’s hard to be truthful about the not-nice stuff interpersonally, not just around protecting the privacy of other people, but because I also know that how I talk about someone, how I present someone or a situation with them creates a representation of them a lot of people read here. I never want anyone I care for and love to be disliked by anyone — heck, even if and when I dislike them, which isn’t the case here, but certainly has been in a couple previous relationships of mine I’ve journaled about. I absolutely don’t want anyone to think someone in my life is a jerk because of what I say, or because people who know or read me feel a loyalty to me, rather than to that other person. Talk about unfair. I can see how, over the years, from an outsider’s view it probably looks like I’m with someone and with someone and then BOOM: I’m not. I can see how it probably presents a lot of my relationships as a bit one-dimensional, since I tend to talk more about their strengths than their flaws. But again, I’m not anonymous here, and often, neither are the people I’m involved with. I think being responsible around that inevitably means presentations that are often fair-weather.
That’s played a part in both of these relationships and my silence around them of late. That loyalty made me want to withhold that Blue was married because I felt protective about anyone leaping to cliched notions about him and thinking he’s a bad person: I know he’s not and I have loved him dearly for nearly all of my adult life. That made me want to withhold some things about what has been going on with Mark and myself because I love and care for him deeply and hate the idea of even someone he’d never meet having a fleeting thought that he’s a jerk because it’s so easy to do with only slices of a picture or only my own words.
To keep you in the loop with more practical stuff, Mark and I have stayed living together throughout, which has been okay sometimes; not so okay at other times. It’s come to the point where we both clearly need some more space. That means one of us leaving the big old house that we rent, and based on a bunch of issues (I’ve done much of the work to it, it has things I need or like but Mark doesn’t, it’s trickier for me to find a good place because I don’t have a car, etc.) we’ve decided I’m going to stay here. I still intend to try and move to the islands, so Mark may even come back here and take over when I can do that (probably not until next summer, mostly due to the health stuff and its expenses). And Blue is planning to move to Seattle to be with me in the next few months, which most likely means moving in here.
I keep going on tangents which I know are coming out of left-field — a very defensive left-field, no less — but I’m going on them all the same. I feel the need to say that this is probably, from an outside perspective, seeming a bit fast. From the inside track, though, it feels like something we have both waited for for close to two decades. We were also Olympic Gold U-Haulers when we got together in college. Our first “date” lasted three solid days and we moved in together right on its heels. It’s probably the most stereotypically dykey thing I have ever done, and I did it with a guy. Figures. All the same, we loved living together, it never felt too fast, and we lived very harmoniously for a few years at a time in our lives when we barely knew how to live alone. We figure we’re probably better at it now. To boot, when we were together the first time we always basically headed these small collective households. They were lovely — I often miss our shared house with Becky and Thai and all the kittens a ton. However, the idea of actually being able to live by ourselves for the first time is pretty exciting.
Where things will go from there, where we’ll want to take them, we don’t know. We’re not there yet and don’t feel a need to be there yet. It’s been one of those things where you just jump. You don’t have to, but you so want to and you can, so jump you do. We’re still mid-air, so who the heck knows where we’ll find ourselves when we land.
The timing of all of this has been seriously rough, or maybe perfect, depending on how you look at it. If Mark had not shared with me what he did, and our relationship hadn’t changed markedly because of it, then we’d still probably have been negotiating switching from primaries to secondaries a few months back. We’d probably also still have been doing that even if Blue had wanted to choose for he and I to stick to a friendship, or if Blue was going to stay in his marriage. Hell, the this of this has been rough. Even from when Blue and I first just started talking again, I was endlessly checking in with Mark because he knew how I felt about Blue: he knew in the first six months we were dating, as I told him about the relationship way back then, before we got to Act III of it. But of course, I didn’t tell him about it with any expectation that that relationship was anything but over. (In hindsight I’m glad of that: I never had to wonder if I was honest about my feelings.) I never thought any of this was going to be easy, but I do think all three of us thought it wasn’t going to be this hard. We’ve all been clumsy, we’ve all had our moments of thinking and feeling we have loused everything up or taken missteps. Maybe we have, any of us, all of us, but all things considered, I think we’ve all done alarmingly well in caring for everyone involved. And that’s not something I’m simply saying out of loyalty, either.
On a strangely bright note, my parents, who got along for five whole minutes of my life and have agreed on things less often than the fingers I have on one hand (the one without all its original fingers, no less), have both been incredibly supportive. Oddly enough, my father was the one with some issues at first — usually, it’d be my mother with the finger-wags — but at this point, they’ve both been great. And that’s been a real and unexpected source of comfort. My friends have also been totally amazing.
On the health front, for the last two weeks, I have finally gotten feeling in my left arm and hand 100% back. I also have been almost entirely without the constant pain in that arm and shoulder. I cannot begin to tell you how amazing it is to have months of that be over, even though I am still enormously behind in everything from the months it went on for. I’m still having weekly therapies for that and some of my other symptoms and issues — muscle work, acupuncture, nasty-tasting herbs — and we still don’t know why it happened, or why I have some other things going on. But to be plain, the pain and numbness being gone, having full use of that hand back, is enough for me for right now. I can live without that question answered at the moment.
However, in a lot of ways, all this health business has been a bit of a straw breaking the proverbial camel’s back.
I need to accept, I’ve been trying to accept, that I simply can’t do 60+ hour workweeks anymore. I need eight hours of sleep a night. I need to take plenty of breaks during the day, especially breaks to play outside where I can move my body around and turn off the incessant furnace of my brain. I need downtime in the evening, and I need something close to two days off a week, not two hours. I turn 40 next year, not 20. I need time for my freaking art, including creating things I have no intention of showing or selling. I also need more flexibility to call it a day when I’ve worked with someone in any given day who has just emotionally tapped me out: the longer I work in the fields I do, the more easily people very deeply connect to me, the more rough stuff they disclose and ask me to help them hold. Sometimes I can hold it and move through the rest of my day, able to hold more. Sometimes I just can’t. That needs to be okay: I need room for that to be okay.
And on top of all of that, with as much diplomacy as I can muster, have to say that I want to be able to have the time when all of the preexisting context of all this is sorted (which may be a seriously long haul) to simply enjoy Blue and being with Blue. Without attaching any sort of hierarchy to any of the relationships in my life, including my relationship with Mark, I am on the precipice of being able to spend a lot of time with someone I have loved for an age, and to be with him in a way that it seems we are both finally ready for. In so many ways, there was an unwieldy enormity to our relationship and chemistry the first time around, and for us individually in terms of dealing with very difficult issues in our own lives. It was a LOT of relationship, a crazy-quick depth of connectivity, some very strange fateful details, and no small measure of drama; a lot of for two relatively young and very passionate people with poor relationship modeling growing up to handle. At this stage in our lives, we are much more capable of both handling it and appreciating it for the rare, mighty thing that it is and always was. Then, it felt like trying to be out in a thunderstorm holding nothing but an umbrella, more likely to get you electrocuted than it was to offer any shelter. Now I think we’ve both got handfuls of thunderbolts and a far greater strength, care and power to use them wisely and without so much fear.
The both of us, albeit in different sorts of ways and on different schedules until the last year, have been hoping for a chance again for a long time. The only things I’ve waited for this long in my life have been health insurance, world peace, the passage of the ERA and a perfect vegan donut (I at least got the last when I moved here). That it seems we’re going to have it feels pretty miraculous and incredibly unlikely. I get to find out what happens when you get, and take, the second chance you never thought you’d get but always wanted. Strangely, this is one of the few times in my life where I find I am not worried about what happens after, not even thinking about what happens after. I don’t know why I’m feeling that way, especially about something so huge and potentially disastrous, but I don’t particularly care. I’m just delighted TO be feeling that way for a change. It’s very freeing.
So, sometime soon, I need to sit down and figure out what has to go in my life: which projects, which jobs, which way I use my time. Some things simply have to go or get cut back to make room for everything else or I’m either going to lose my mind or do myself in with sheer exhaustion.
Okay. So, that’s what I’ve got for now. It’s a lot, I know. Believe me, I know. The funny thing is, it feels like I’ve only addressed a little, just kind of opened the door a sliver. But I had to open it: the longer it sat closed, the more uncomfortable and dishonest it felt, and the more was going to bust out of it when I finally did open it.
I have some silly, light stuff to tell, but putting that here before I just spit out some of the other stuff felt disingenuous, so I can get to that stuff soon now. Writing those trifles is easy as pie. The other stuff? Not easy. And perhaps not graceful either, but at least it’s done. I’ve got trembly fingers, but I’m going to push that button that says publish, even though “save” seems more fitting.
P.S. I think the most gracious way to handle this per saying so much, including about other people’s private lives as well as my own, is to password this entry in a little while. So, I’ll leave it up for all for around a week, then it’s going somewhere more protected.

Several weeks ago, on the way home from the movies, Mark, Heath and I drove by a shop with this hat in the window, which caused a great squealingy ruckus on my part.




